Copyright in the digital era

ziggy on 2002-10-27T19:23:09

[US Copyright Register Marybeth] Peters believes that many "fair use" practices consumers take for granted, such as taping a TV program or copying a magazine article, need to be re-evaluated in the digital age because the economic harm to copyright owners is far greater. For instance, she believes song-swapping over the Internet, popularized by Napster, is illegal.

"Some of the activities you tolerate in a nondigital world are because of the inefficiency of making the copy, how the copy is degraded and the difficulty in sending copies to someone beyond yourself," Peters said. "All of those things go away in a digital environment."

-- Library official at center of digital rights fight

Funny how there are no simple answers in the copyright reform debate, unless you take a radical position to completely ignore the other side's concerns. (I'm talking about you Messrs. Valenti and Stallman.)


Perfect copies?

djberg96 on 2002-10-27T23:59:49

As an occasional downloader of mp3 files, I can tell you that I've sampled lots of files that have had bytes missing and/or sound like junk in general. I've probably trashed more than I've kept. Quality *does* degrade after repeated swapping, generally speaking.

I'd say about 80% of my mp3 collection is my own stuff and it sounds the best - mostly because I use a good program (Ripenc in BeOS using LAME) and a the highest quality bitrate - space be damned.