Gosling on C#

ziggy on 2002-03-30T16:54:58

From Computerworld:

Q: What's the old saying, it's the sincerest form of flattery?

A: Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery.

Q: Did you feel that way when you saw C#?

A: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, abused and ripped off was also in there just to some extent. Relieved actually was part of it.

Q: Relieved?

A: That it wasn't particularly creative.

Virtual machines and cross-language interfaces are in vogue at the moment. (They've been around in some sort or another since about 1978 from what I remember; the cross-language aspect is something of a newer wrinkle.)

Gosling's remarks beg the question: are we doing something creative with Parrot/Perl6? Or is it just a simple application of existing technique with no new ideas? And do Gosling's opinions really matter that much to us?


Creative?

Whammo on 2002-03-30T20:38:18

No, of course not. Not directly. But this is Perl. We live off of stealing ideas from elsewhere and repackaging them, sometimes in creative ways.