The Point behind the Semantic Web

ziggy on 2003-11-08T20:45:49

Clay Shirky has an interesting take on the point behind the Semantic Web:

The Semantic Web specifies ways of exposing these kinds of assertions on the Web, so that third parties can combine them to discover things that are true but not specified directly. This is the promise of the Semantic Web -- it will improve all the areas of your life where you currently use syllogisms.

Which is to say, almost nowhere.

Shirky's essay is possibly the biggest and most thorough condemnation of the semantic web that I've ever read. (That statement in and of itself says quite a lot.)


interesting

inkdroid on 2003-11-08T23:14:13

Yes, this was a fun essay. The one thing I think he gets wrong is that the semantic web =~ AI. I don't think that this is the point of SW at all.

semantic bray

inkdroid on 2003-11-10T03:10:21

If you haven't yet, be sure to check out Tim Bray's measured response