Unearthed apple power supplies

nicholas on 2004-12-21T11:46:00

Run your finger across the Powerbook, for example just below the space bar, and sometimes it doesn't feel smooth - the finger vibrates as if there is a very fine ribbing on the metal. This is strange, because the same metal feels totally smooth to the same finger at other times. So we decided to investigate further.

It seems that sometimes if you're sitting with a Powerbook on your lap, your skin feels rough to someone else touching it. And you can give them small electric shocks. It probably helped that the other person also had a Powerbook on their lap. However, the most "interesting" thing you can do is rub your finger on the skin just in front of you co-experimenter's ear. Not only will it feel rough, but the will hear a low buzzing. We're not sure of the frequency, but we have this suspicion that it's 50Hz. (At least for experiments conducted in the UK). So what's up?

Apple power adaptors for Powerbooks consist of a small white "brick" into which various leads can be plugged. In the US a long earthed lead is supplied. In the UK, a long earthed lead is supplied, but also a small triangular unearthed plug. US leads can be used in the UK with a mains socket adaptor, but some of these only connect the live and neutral, leaving the earth unconnected.

It seems that if you're using the power supply unearthed, for various of the above permutations including the official Apple product for the UK, the aluminium skin of the powerbook is carrying a small current. I have a suspicion that it's earthed via the outher sheath of the power connector into the laptop, that earth cable goes all the way back to the brick, where it floats because there is no onward earthing, and that nice long wire gets a current induced from the mains hum, or possibly because some part of the AC circuitry is earthed to it. And if someone who is nicely earthed (for example using a Powerbook attached to an earthed power supply) touches the Powerbook, or a user "earthed" to it, you can create small shocks. My multimeter suggests it's about 0.4V AC between the earthed Powerbook. Shocking!


have had this for a long time

tannie on 2004-12-21T12:15:23

I always used the earthed cable and the problem still occured. I thought I had made a comment about this in CPH to you (maybe not, maybe to someone else). I never noticed the hum, but sure noticed the friction. Plus I think i had minor shocks when I had sweaty hands and wearing my bracelet (it had a hanging part that would occasionally touch the powerbook at that spot right next to the mousepad belw the spacebar). Good to know, after two years, that it's not me ;)

Re:have had this for a long time

nicholas on 2004-12-21T16:15:05

Ah right. I was sure someone had mentioned it before, and tried to find a reference to it on use.perl. I think that acme mentioned it at some point too.

low boil

jhi on 2004-12-21T17:10:31

So only do not one's family jools get bathed in radio frequencies but they will get gently electrocuted, too?

Re:low boil

nicholas on 2004-12-21T19:05:58

Not if they're safely at the same potential as the rest of the case, I believe. I think that the only danger is if they're one's only point of contact with someone (or something) else that is earthed:

"Did the earth move for you?"

"No, but you caused some interesting tingling sensations."

Short Arms

jonasbn on 2005-01-07T08:53:13

This is a an annoying problem for me, since I rest my arms on the frame when typing and it then hurts my arms.

I am writing this on a fully charged battery and the sensation does not occur, so I think it only seems to happen when the machine is charging.

A funny thing was, when the other day I could feel the current on my girlfriends back, when she was using my TiBook.

Re: Unearthed apple power supplies

dbell on 2005-01-14T17:24:58

This live chassis issue is very common, and very old. The description of the touch sensation as like a surface roughness is dead on, too! The problem stems from the fact that the actual power supply (in the mains adapter) is completely floating with respective to the earth ground. There is a very small capacitive coupling from both sides of the supply to the chassis, essentially making a voltage divider that places the chassis at half the mains voltage above ground. In the UK, that's roughly 120 volts AC, and would be disasterous, if the voltage divider's source impedance wasn't extremely high. As it is, all you feel is a slight tingling. It's harmless but annoying, and some people will not notice it, at all. As you all have found, grounding the case with the proper adapter cord will always eliminate the problem. Oh - and it has nothing to do with the battery actually charging; even if you have a fully charged battery, having the laptop connected to the mains adapter is all that's needed...

Dave