We put the dot in .. anecdote

Robrt on 2003-04-14T01:18:04

I want to know who at Sun decided that servers should have power management enabled by default.

Ask and I went to the data center today to find out why one of our boxes dropped off the net. It went to sleep!

powerd is now disabled.


depends on your definition of default

hfb on 2003-04-14T05:37:40

with a manual install the powerd question is part of the routine so it's only on by default if you aren't paying attention or don't have it configured in your jumpstart config. Besides, most people who can afford $20k and up for a server usually can spare a few bucks for a UPS :) kill vold too.

Re: SUN & power management.

Abigail on 2003-04-14T10:53:48

I've pondered that question myself in the past as well. I finally decided to blame environment friendly California. SUN is located in California, and I wouldn't be surprised if there was a state law demanding this to be turned on by default. And it it isn't true, I'd like to believe so.

Abigail

Re: SUN & power management.

hfb on 2003-04-15T17:49:52

it's not on by default though as it asks you 3 times if you wish to enable it. I suppose they figure the random amateurs won't notice and it might save a lot of power on desktops and idling boxes...but it seems to catch a few people who should know how to read the banner on reboot asking if you /really/ want to enable powerd :)

If it asks you three times I don't think it can really be considered 'default' :)

Re: SUN & power management.

Robrt on 2003-04-15T20:41:22

It definitely didn't ask me three times.

Re: SUN & power management.

hfb on 2003-04-15T21:04:49

You must have just missed them then as it asks and even waits for a response on the reboot though I don't recall if it has a timeout.

from the manpage...

The default behavior is mandated by the U.S. Government Environmental Protection Agency as a requirement for EnergyStar compliance. The user will be prompted to confirm this default at system installation reboot, or during the first boot after the system is unconfigured by sys-unconfig(1M).

and since it asks to confirm, I don't think it's technically a default install like, say, nscd or something like that.