Wiki Graffiti

Matts on 2004-02-07T11:12:25

I've been suffering lately from Wiki spammers on the AxKit wiki. The spammers are simply adding links in to their porn pages to get a higher google pagerank.

I do not like this one bit. But what can I do?

The surprising thing is that they are actually adding the links in POD format. So someone is either already a perl programmer, or taking the time to learn the format to add the links in. And it's obviously not automated.

The worst thing is that the AxKit wiki maintains a linked in history, so even when I revert the change the spammer still has those links in place in the history view.

One possible solution is to require a login. But I hate that idea. Another possible solution is to show the raw content in the history view (i.e. raw POD) so that links aren't links. But that doesn't mean I stop having the job of janitor.

spammers suck.


Moderation

jonasbn on 2004-02-07T17:18:15

What about moderation with approval?

use a redirect script

kellan on 2004-02-07T17:39:23

instead of linking directly to external URLs have your formatter point them to a redirect script thus negating the Google value of the links. if the spammers are adding links by hand they'll figure it out quickly.

Re:use a redirect script

Matts on 2004-02-08T16:25:24

Ah, thanks for this idea. This is the option I've chosen (as it's the simplest to implement). I wrote a little redirector that makes sure the referrer contains one of my domains (to stop email/spam use) and now all external links go through that.

I also added a page for porn spammers to go and read, and added it to all the "Edit" screens so hopefully they will go and read it.

Login to Edit

dws on 2004-02-07T17:55:33

Several of the Wikis that I run are set up for public viewing, but require a login to edit. One of these Wikis has been up for four years, and I've received exactly one (mild) complaint.

<plug type="shameless">
One of the Wikis is for the AYE Conference, a no-vendor people issues in technology conference put on by a group of consultants and software managers that Gerald (Jerry) Weinberg has trained.We use the Wiki to gather feedback and suggestions about the conference sessions. Folks who register get a login and can contribute; everyone else can read along.
</plug>

honey pots for google spammers

mock on 2004-02-16T23:41:24

Once upon a time when I worked in the SEO business I wrote some code which auto submitted anyone who added an url to google's spam report http://www.google.com/contact/spamreport.html Worked quite nicely as a trap for our competitors. You could probably add something similar quite easily.